Comparison

A Givebutter and Donorbox alternative for nonprofits

Donation tools are built for ongoing giving on your own website. Pledzy is a campaign platform with reward tiers, review and local discovery — at a 3% nonprofit rate.

Givebutter and Donorbox are donation software. You embed a form on your own site, collect recurring gifts and run events or peer-to-peer drives. Both are strong at that, and Givebutter's tip-supported model can bring the platform fee to zero.

Pledzy is not donation software. It is a campaign platform: a deadline, a goal, reward tiers, a reviewed public page and an audience browsing their own city. If your problem is being found by new local supporters rather than processing gifts from people who already know you, that is the difference.

Pledzy vs Givebutter and Donorbox

PledzyGivebutter and Donorbox
What it isA campaign platform with a goal, deadline and rewardsDonation forms and pages for your own website
What supporters getA reward tier you defineA receipt and a thank-you
Finding new supportersCity and state hubs, browse, deadline listingsYou bring your own traffic
Nonprofit fee3% for verified nonprofits, plus 2.9% + 30¢ processingVaries — tip-supported or a platform percentage, plus processing
Recurring givingNot offered — campaigns are one-off raisesCore feature, including monthly donors
ReviewEvery campaign reviewed before it goes publicAccount onboarding checks
Also for businessesYes — same platform for for-profit local businessesNonprofit and cause focused
Choose Pledzy if
  • You are running a specific project with a goal and a deadline.
  • You can offer rewards or perks, not just a receipt.
  • You want to be discovered by people browsing their own city.
  • You want your campaign reviewed and your organization verified.
Choose Givebutter and Donorbox if
  • You need recurring monthly donors and donor management.
  • You want a donate button embedded in your own website.
  • Tax-deductible receipting and CRM features are your priority.

Common questions

Are Pledzy contributions tax-deductible?

Backers receive a reward in exchange, so a contribution is generally not a straightforward deductible gift. Talk to your accountant, and be clear with supporters on your campaign page.

Can we use both?

Yes, and many organizations do — a donation tool for ongoing giving on your website, and a Pledzy campaign when you have a specific project to fund.

Keep reading

Start a campaign